10 Best Homeowners Insurance Companies of 2023

William Huston, AIF®, AIFA®

William Huston, AIF®, AIFA®

10 Best Homeowners Insurance Companies of 2023


If you're a homeowner, choosing the right homeowners insurance company is crucial for protecting one of your most valuable assets, your home. In 2023, there are several insurance companies that have consistently proven their commitment to customer satisfaction, comprehensive coverage options and reliable claims handling.

In this article, we will explore some of these top-rated homeowners insurance companies, highlighting their strengths and why they are considered leaders in the industry. Whether you're a first-time homeowner or looking to switch providers, understanding the best options available can help you make an informed decision and provide peace of mind knowing your home is well-protected.

Before you go ahead and purchase a policy, it is important that you consult a certified financial planner and real estate professional , so they can provide guidance in helping you select the best policy for you. If you would like to go ahead and purchase an insurance policy, you can do so here .

Key Takeaways
  • Buying a good homeowners insurance policy is crucial for protecting your home, which is most likely one of your most valuable asset
  • Homeowners insurance, also known as home insurance, is a type of property insurance that provides financial protection to homeowners against various risks and dangers
  • Some of the best home insurance companies of 2023 include: Allstate, American Family, Amica, Chubb, Erie, Farmers, Lemonade, Nationwide, State Farm and USAA

The contents of this article are for educational purposes only. They are not intended to be a source of professional financial advice. You will find experts on financial planning, financial management, and real estate here. More on disclaimers here.

What is Homeowners Insurance?


Homeowners insurance, also known as home insurance, is a type of property insurance that provides financial protection to homeowners against various risks and dangers. It is designed to help cover the costs of repairing or rebuilding a home, replacing personal belongings and addressing liability claims resulting from accidents or injuries that occur on the property.

Homeowners insurance typically consists of several key coverages:

Dwelling coverage

This coverage provides financial protection for the physical structure of your home. It is designed to cover the costs of repairing or rebuilding your house in the event of covered risks such as fire, hail, windstorm or vandalism.

Personal property coverage

This type of coverage helps protect your personal belongings such as furniture, clothing, electronics and appliances from dangers like theft, fire or certain types of water damage. It provides reimbursement for the cost of repairing or replacing these items, up to the coverage limit specified in your policy.

Liability coverage

Liability coverage helps protect you financially if someone is injured on your property or if you accidentally cause damage to someone else's property. It can help cover legal expenses, medical bills and other costs associated with liability claims or lawsuits.

Additional living expenses (ALE) coverage

If your home becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event, ALE coverage helps cover temporary living expenses such as hotel stays, meals and transportation while your home is being repaired or rebuilt.

Medical payments coverage

This coverage helps pay for medical expenses if a guest is injured on your property, regardless of who is at fault. It can cover costs such as medical treatment, ambulance fees and hospital bills.

Best Home Insurance Companies of 2023

These made our top-10 list:

1. Allstate


Allstate is known for its focus on offering personalized coverage options and customer service. The company offers various endorsements and optional coverages that allow homeowners to customize their policies based on their specific needs. These may include coverage for high-value items, identity theft protection and increased limits for liability.

  • Allstate has a vast network of local agents across the country. This means you can work directly with an agent who can provide personalized service, answer your questions and assist with your insurance needs.
  • Provides user-friendly online tools and resources for managing your policy, making payments and filing a home insurance claim.
  • Offers various discounts and savings opportunities to help homeowners reduce their insurance premiums.
  • Does not serve clients in all states.
  • While many customers report positive experiences with their agents and claims handling, some have expressed dissatisfaction with the level of service provided.

2. American Family

American Family

Based in Wisconsin, American Family is the 7th biggest home insurance company in the U.S. It offers its clients different home insurance packages such as dwelling coverage, other structures coverage, personal property coverage, liability insurance and additional living expenses coverage.

  • Affordable home insurance packages.
  • Great customer service.
  • Offer extended and guaranteed replacement for dwellings in the case where the cost of rebuilding exceeds the insurance limit of the house.
  • Has a banned dog list.
  • You have to engage an agent in order for you to purchase a policy.

3. Amica


Amica Mutual Insurance Company is an insurance provider that offers home and auto insurance policies to its clients. With a strong reputation for customer service and financial stability, Amica offers its clients both basic and premium home insurance policies.

  • Offers user-friendly online tools and resources, allowing homeowners to manage their policies, make payments and file claims conveniently. They also have a mobile app for easy access to policy information and assistance.
  • Has a range of coverage options for homeowners as well as home insurance discounts.
  • Operates in a limited number of states. If you reside outside their service area, you may not be able to obtain coverage from them.
  • While Amica is known for its high-quality service, their premiums may be higher compared to some other insurance providers.

4. Chubb


For owners of high-end and luxury homes, Chubb is a great homeowners insurance company to consider as homeowners get to work with specialized agents to help them determine the best products for them. They offer their clients services such as risk consulting, cash settlement in case your house is destroyed and you decide not to rebuild or to rebuild at another location.

Chubb also makes use of HomeScan, a tool that can reveal leaks, missing insulation and faulty electrical connections before significant damage happens.

  • In the case of total destruction of a house, Chubb offers its clients the choice to rebuild or to rebuild at another location
  • Offers a cash settlement, up to the client's policy limit.
  • Offers various additional coverages that can be added to homeowners insurance policies such as tree removal after a storm and lock replacement if your keys are lost or stolen.
  • No banned dog list.
  • Higher cost of home insurance coverage than other insurance companies.

5. Erie

Erie Insurance

If you're looking for a homeowners insurance policy with competitive rates, good coverage options and great customer service, then you should consider getting a homeowners insurance cover with Erie.

If you live in any of the 12 states that the company serves, and Washington D.C., you can enjoy both standard and guaranteed replacement cost coverage options for your dwelling. This can help you rebuild your house in case of a disaster.

  • Great customer service as clients get to work with specialized independent agents.
  • Offers competitive premiums for homeowners insurance coverage.
  • If you bundle your homeowners insurance with other types of coverage, such as auto insurance, you can be eligible for discounted rates, which can help you save money.
  • Only available to clients in 12 states and Washington D.C.
  • Has a banned dog breed list.

6. Farmers

Farmers Insurance

Farmers is well known for its reliable coverage, personalized service and commitment to customer satisfaction.

They offer various options and endorsements to customize your policy based on your specific needs. You can adjust coverage limits, add specific coverage for valuable items or choose additional endorsements to enhance your policy.

  • Provide efficient claims service to policyholders and have a 24/7 claims reporting system and a dedicated claims team that works to handle claims promptly and assist with the claims process.
  • Offer extended and guaranteed replacement cost options.
  • No banned dog list.
  • The cost of their home insurance policies are on the higher side as compared to their competitors.

7. Lemonade


Lemonade is a modern and innovative homeowners insurance company that has gained popularity for its unique approach to insurance. With a strong emphasis on technology, simplicity and social impact, Lemonade aims to provide homeowners with a hassle-free and socially responsible insurance experience.

The company offers their clients policies that cover your home and property for damage caused by things like wildfires, extreme weather, crime and vandalism.

  • Provides a simple and intuitive mobile app, allowing homeowners to get a quote, purchase a policy and manage their insurance easily.
  • The company makes use of artificial intelligence and automation to handle claims efficiently, often providing payouts within minutes.
  • Lemonade's homeowners insurance policies are not available nationwide as they operate in a select number of states.
  • No in-person agent support as Lemonade does not have local agents.

8. Nationwide


Nationwide is an insurance company that offers its clients standard home insurance packages as well as private client insurance for high-net worth homeowners.

They offer payment of up to $500 for losses made on unauthorized credit or debit card transactions, forged checks and counterfeit money. They also offer specialized coverage that allows policy holders to cash out in case their home is destroyed, accidental breakage of items such as crystal and china and breakdown of home appliances.

  • Offers comprehensive coverage options for homeowners, including flood and earthquake are optional coverages.
  • Provides various discounts and savings opportunities to help homeowners reduce their insurance premiums.
  • They don't have a banned dog list.
  • While Nationwide offers competitive pricing, it's important to compare quotes from different insurance providers to ensure you are getting the best rate for your specific needs.
  • Operates in most states but may have limited availability in certain areas such as Alaska, Florida, Hawaii, Louisiana, New Jersey, New Mexico and Massachusetts.

9. State Farm

State Farm

State Farm home insurance offers coverage options that include dwelling protection, personal property coverage and liability protection which helps to cover legal expenses and financial responsibility if someone is injured on your property or if you unintentionally cause damage to someone else's property.

  • The price of the premiums is lower than the national average.
  • The standard policy also includes extra protection.
  • Provide their clients with user-friendly online tools and resources for managing their policy, making payments and filing claims.
  • Offer fewer discounts as compared to other home insurance providers
  • Clients can only access services through agents.

10. USAA


For people serving in the military, USAA can be a good option as they're military focused and understand their unique needs and tailor make services for them. The insurance company offers policies that cover things like weather related damage, theft and vandalism and sudden and accidental water and mold damage.

  • Known for its competitive pricing, offering affordable premiums for home insurance coverage.
  • Excellent customer service.
  • No banned dog list.
  • Offers additional coverages and endorsements that may include coverage for valuables, identity theft and earthquake or flood insurance.
  • Membership is restricted to active military personnel, veterans and their immediate family members.

How to Choose the Best Homeowners Insurance Policy

Homeowner researching insurance policies online

Choosing the best homeowners insurance policy requires careful consideration of various factors. Here are some steps to help you make an informed decision:

Assess your needs

Evaluate your home and belongings to determine the level of coverage you require. Consider the replacement cost of your home, the value of your personal belongings and any specific risks you may face based on your location or property features.

Research insurance providers

Look for reputable insurance companies that specialize in homeowners insurance. Consider factors such as financial stability, customer service reputation and the range of coverage options they offer.

Compare quotes

Obtain quotes from multiple insurance providers to compare pricing and coverage. Make sure you're comparing policies with similar coverage limits, deductibles and endorsements to get an accurate comparison.

Understand coverage details

Review the policy documents and understand what is covered, any exclusions or limitations and the claims process. Pay attention to coverage for dwelling, personal property, liability and additional living expenses, as well as any optional coverages you may need.

Consider deductibles

Evaluate the deductible options available and determine the amount you are comfortable paying out of pocket in the event of a claim. Keep in mind that a higher deductible may lower your premium but require more out-of-pocket expenses if you need to file a claim.

Research customer reviews

Read customer reviews and testimonials to get insights into the customer experience with each insurance provider. Look for feedback on claims handling, customer service and overall satisfaction.

Seek professional advice

Consult with an independent insurance agent or broker who can provide personalized recommendations based on your specific needs. They can help you navigate the options, explain policy details and answer any questions you may have.

Bundle policies if applicable

If you have other insurance needs, such as auto or life insurance, consider bundling policies with the same insurance provider. Many companies offer multi-policy discounts, which can result in cost savings.

Review periodically

Regularly review your homeowners insurance policy to ensure it continues to meet your needs. As your circumstances change, such as home renovations or the acquisition of valuable items, you may need to update your coverage.


Remember, the best homeowners insurance policy will be the one that provides the right level of coverage, suits your budget and offers excellent customer service. Taking the time to research and compare options will help you choose a policy that offers peace of mind and protection for your home and belongings.

Bay Street Capital Holdings

Bay Street Capital Holdings

Bay Street Capital Holdings is a Black-owned investment advisory, wealth management and financial planning firm headquartered in Palo Alto, CA. They manage portfolios with the goal of maintaining and increasing total assets and income with a high priority on managing total risk and volatility. Although many advisors may focus on maximizing returns, they place a higher priority on managing total risk and volatility.

Founded by William Huston after 13 years of supporting the United States' largest retirement plan ($650B) Thrift Savings Plan, Bay Street was founded to advocate for diverse and emerging fund managers and entrepreneurs. In 2021, William was recognized among Investopedia’s Top 100 Financial Advisors for 2021.

In California, only two Black-owned firms out of nineteen firms received this recognition. In the same year, Bay Street was selected as a finalist out of over 900 firms across the US in the category of Asset Manager for Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR).

In Scottsdale Arizona, Ekenna Anya-Gafu CFP, AAMS is recognized among the Best Financial Advisors for his responsiveness, friendliness, helpfulness, and detail.







Let's Talk

Schedule a complimentary consultation with one of our advisors to learn more about Bay Street and how we can help you achieve your goals for your financial future.

form img